Fishers Homes with Not In Subdivision Lot features

Fishers Homes with Not In Subdivision Lot features

Welcome to Fishers, Indiana—a vibrant and growing city that perfectly blends suburban charm with urban conveniences. Nestled in Hamilton County, Fishers is known for its friendly community atmosphere, top-notch schools, and an array of recreational options. Just a short drive from downtown Indianapolis, this city offers residents the best of both worlds: the tranquility of suburban life coupled with easy access to big-city amenities.

One of the most appealing aspects of Fishers is its diverse housing market, particularly the unique opportunity to own homes with "Not in Subdivision" lot features. These properties provide an exceptional sense of privacy and individuality, allowing homeowners to create their own personal oasis. Imagine living in a spacious home surrounded by lush greenery, where you can enjoy outdoor gatherings, gardening, or simply unwinding in your own serene space.

Fishers is also home to a thriving economy, with numerous shopping, dining, and entertainment options. The Fishers District and the popular Nickel Plate District are bustling hubs where you can explore a variety of restaurants, boutiques, and parks. Residents enjoy an active lifestyle, with access to numerous walking trails, parks, and community events throughout the year.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, Fishers offers a welcoming community and diverse housing options that cater to every lifestyle. Discover the charm of Fishers and explore the unique possibilities of owning a home with Not in Subdivision lot features—where your dream home awaits!

Newest Fishers Homes with Not In Subdivision Lot features

$800,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Who says you can't have it all? Welcome to this beautifully remodeled one-level brick ranch where luxury, comfort, and incredible space come together on 1.65 private acres in the heart of Fishers! Your own private retreat, yet just minutes from the Fishers Community Center, top-rated schools, shopping, dining, entertainment, and I-69. Inside, every detail shines-from custom Amish-made cabinetry and built-ins throughout to quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a gas cooktop, built-in wall ovens, and a large center island with breakfast bar that's made for everything from pancake mornings to party nights. The vaulted family room with a cozy gas fireplace is ready for movie nights and game days alike. The 4-season Sunroom lets you enjoy the outdoors year-round, while the open patio is perfect for grilling, relaxing, or soaking in the peaceful surroundings. The oversized primary suite is your own private getaway, complete with a spa-inspired bath featuring a stunning tile walk-in shower and HEATED tile floors! Bedrooms two and three share a full hall bath, and the fourth bedroom-with its built-in desk-is ideal as a home office, guest room, or creative space. Everyday living is easy with a mudroom featuring a utility sink and half bath, plus custom locker cubbies! Need room for cars, hobbies, toys, or a business? You've found it! Home has an oversized attached two-car garage plus a detached 2+ car garage with attic loft and extra storage. An OUTBUILDING that is an impressive 30' x 48' pole barn complete with its own HVAC system, half bath, and separate gas meter. Workshop? Home gym? Collector's paradise? You decide! Private, polished, and packed with possibilities-this isn't just a house, it's the one you've been waiting for. Properties like this don't come along often, don't miss your chance to call it home. Home offers some handicap-accessibility features.

10765 E 121st Street, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

$409,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Rare 1.54-acre wooded opportunity in a prime Fishers location! Situated just off Cyntheanne Rd, this private lot offers the perfect setting to build your dream home. The existing home and detached garage are being sold AS-IS and will likely require demolition. Due to foundation, roof, and structural issues, the improvements are not considered suitable for renovation. The property is currently serviced by well water, septic system, and propane gas. Enjoy the rare combination of privacy and convenience with no HOA, while being just minutes from Hamilton Town Center, Geist Reservoir, top-rated HSE Schools, parks, dining, shopping, and I-69. Build the custom home you've always wanted on this exceptional 1.54-acre homesite!

13182 Cyntheanne Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Complete.

$409,900
Rare 1.54-acre wooded opportunity in a prime Fishers location! Situated just off Cyntheanne Rd, this private lot offers the perfect setting to build your dream home. The existing home and detached garage are being sold AS-IS and will likely require demolition. Due to foundation, roof, and structural issues, the improvements are not considered suitable for renovation. The property is currently serviced by well water, septic system, and propane gas. Enjoy the rare combination of privacy and convenience with no HOA, while being just minutes from Hamilton Town Center, Geist Reservoir, top-rated HSE Schools, parks, dining, shopping, and I-69. Build the custom home you've always wanted on this exceptional 1.54-acre homesite!

13182 Cyntheanne Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Complete.

$1,999,900
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths
A private sanctuary where luxury, nature, and everyday living come together in perfect harmony. Tucked behind a gated entrance on over 5.5 wooded acres in the heart of Fishers, this exceptional 5-bedroom estate offers the perfect blend of privacy, luxury, and convenience. Meticulously maintained and thoughtfully enhanced by the current owners, the home features significant recent improvements, including a newly finished walkout basement with a full bathroom and plumbing for a future wet bar, two new high-efficiency heat pumps (2024), a new roof with gutter guards (2025), and numerous additional updates throughout. Ideal for multigenerational living, the home also offers a luxurious main-level primary suite and a private guest or in-law suite with its own separate entrance. Inside, you'll find soaring ceilings, hickory hardwood floors, two fireplaces, and walls of windows overlooking the tranquil wooded setting. The chef's kitchen showcases custom cherry cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, a stacked slate backsplash, and an oversized center island. Upstairs offers three additional bedrooms plus a spacious private suite with sitting room and separate entrance-perfect for a home office, guest quarters, or potential apartment. The newly finished walkout lower level features 9'+ ceilings, abundant natural light, extensive storage, a full bath and plumbing for a future wet bar. Enjoy the outdoors from the expansive deck, screened porch, all surrounded by mature trees. An oversized three-car garage with epoxy flooring completes this remarkable estate. A rare opportunity to enjoy secluded luxury just minutes from Fishers' premier shopping, dining, and amenities.

12815 Olio Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC.

$2,925,000
Design & build your dream home, on the lake in Fishers IN - 1 of Hamilton County's most desirable cities.Ranked #2 Best Place To Live in US, US News&World Report 5/19/2026.Investing in this rare waterfront opport.by purchasing these 3 contiguous buildable lakefronts guarantees a prem foundation for future equity.Combined x-deep lots total 5.85ac nestled in46037 Corridor w/unprecedented approx.1,015'pristine glistening shoreline on crystal clear,priv uncongested Lake Stonebridge-an exceptional opport.to control a strategic footprint.Being offered separately or as a combined holding.Lot 1: 2.72ac w/approx.330'shoreline,incl: 28'x49'pavilion w/restroom&36'x62'outbldg w/restroom for $1,360,000Lot 2: 1.75ac w/ approx340'shoreline for $875,000Lot 3: 1.38ac w/approx.345'shoreline for $690.000.No HOA obligations only annual $325.Lake fee.Priv.boat dock will allow fishing boat&pontoon to 24'w/engine to 9.9 horsepower.Est.50'deep w/shallow parts 30' deep,swim,kayak,fish.6mi NW of popul Geist Reservoir&70-ac waterfront park.Unprecedented conven loc surrounded by multi-mill $homes.5min to NickelPlateDistr,24 parks.Elevated bldg sites w/breathtaking unobstructed,panoramic views over water w/uncrowded lake access.13min to Hamilton Town Ctr.6mi to Championship18-hole golf.w/in 3mi toAward-win HamiltonSoutheastern Sch.For discerning buyers wanting to unplug/relax/enj nature;high-end buyer to host priortize water sports&comm.Earth features/topography obstruct path of sound waves(road to north)&scatter them before they reach your ears-must see it to hear the quiet!Allows you to totally embrace a life of tranquility on secluded acreage.Location offers unbeatable commuter connectivity w/everyday conven&effortless access to major thoroughfares;rapid access I69,SR37,116th St.&Cumberland Rd.EZ access Central IN;25min to dtwn Indy;45min.to Indy Internat.Airport.Ask your agent for the unabbreviated version of this property desctription attached to this listing sheet.

10569 E 116th Street, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Kincaid REALTORS, LLC.

$1,300,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Stepping onto this meticulously renovated 4 bed, 2 baths 1900s farmhouse is like entering a private retreat where historic character meets high-end modern luxury. Sprawling across nearly an acre in the heart of Fishers, this estate is a true original, offering a lifestyle centered around connection, creativity, and world-class entertaining. Inside the main residence, the craftsmanship of a bygone era shines through original built-ins and rich hardwood floors, now seamlessly paired with sophisticated updates. The heart of the home features a stunningly remodeled kitchen and a see-through gas fireplace that adds warmth and ambiance to the living spaces. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, boasting a spa-like bath that opens directly onto a private deck-the perfect spot for a quiet morning coffee. While the interior is captivating, the grounds are designed for those who love to host. The outdoor oasis is anchored by a sparkling inground pool and a relaxing hot tub. For intimate gatherings, look no further than the artfully repurposed smokehouse, now a chic poolside lounge. As the sun sets, the gas firepit becomes the natural gathering spot for stories and relaxation under the stars. The true showstopper is the massive Amish Barn, which has been transformed into a premier recreation destination. Whether you're hosting a performance on the built-in stage, starting a tournament on the dedicated basketball and pickleball courts, or simply enjoying the vast open space, this barn is an entertainer's dream come to life. Complete with a wrap-around front porch that invites you to slow down and three garage spaces for vehicles distributed across the property's structures, this estate is a rare find for the automotive enthusiast. There are simply too many updates and improvements to list here. Come experience a home that isn't just a place to live, but a place to truly celebrate life.

12340 Brooks School Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC.

$330,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This updated Ranch home in Fishers offers comfort, flexibility, and a great location. It features three bedrooms, one and a half bathrooms, hardwood floors throughout most of the home, and ceramic tile in the kitchen and family room. The brand-new kitchen includes modern finishes and a functional layout. The attached garage has a new coated floor, plenty of storage shelving, and a separate craft or workshop room-perfect for hobbies or extra workspace.Crawl space has been professionally Encapsulated. Outside, you'll find a fully fenced backyard with a patio and fire pit, ideal for relaxing or entertaining. The property also offers plenty of parking and convenient access to Allisonville Road, shopping, dining, parks, and major highways. For the past two years, this home has been successfully used as a short-term rental, making it a great option as a primary residence, second home, or investment property. Well maintained and move-in ready, this is a wonderful opportunity in a highly desirable Fishers location.

13165 Allisonville Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Ashkee Realty LLC.

$849,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Truly one of a kind! Nearly 6000 sq ft on a beautiful 1.3 acre lot. Welcome to White Horse Lane, a serene, wooded retreat conveniently located just minutes from schools, shopping, dining, and everyday amenities. Upon entry, you're immediately drawn to the stunning wall of picture windows in the family room, perfectly framing the picturesque wooded setting. The family room is a showstopper, featuring vaulted ceilings with exposed wood beams, a striking stone fireplace, and generous space for gathering and entertaining. The adjacent sunroom offers an additional area to relax or host guests before stepping out onto the deck and screened-in patio-ideal for enjoying the peaceful surroundings.The main level also includes a formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, laundry area, half bath, and a spacious primary suite complete with a sitting area or private office space. Upstairs, you'll find a generously sized en-suite bedroom along with two additional bedrooms connected by a Jack-and-Jill bath. Each bedroom offers abundant built-ins and large closets. The en-suite closet provides access to additional walk-in attic storage. The fully finished walkout basement features a custom-built bar and plenty of additional storage space. Completing the property is a three-car garage, private walking trail, and a setting that truly feels like a retreat. There is so much to love about this exceptional home-you have to see it for yourself!

118 White Horse Lane, Fishers

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

$1,800,000
Exceptional development opportunity in one of Fishers' most desirable areas. This combined 11.5 acre site offers excellent visibility and accessibility along E 131st Street-just steps from Sand Creek Elementary and Intermediate Schools and within walking distance to Fishers High School. All 3 schools are within 0.5 miles of this site. Currently zoned R2 Residential and located within the I-69 Overland Overlay, the property lies in an area designated by the City of Fishers Comprehensive Plan for Suburban Residential development. This supports future single-family residential or compatible neighborhood uses consistent with surrounding developments. With utilities nearby and strong surrounding demographics, this site is ideal for a residential subdivision, custom home sites, or long-term investment in a rapidly growing area of Fishers.

11798 & 11842 E 131st Street, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

$9,950,000
9 Beds ⋅ 12 Baths
Set on 5.23 PRIVATE ACRES with 570' of pristine Geist Reservoir shoreline, this 21,000 sq ft gated waterfront estate redefines Midwestern luxury. A gas-lit, tree-lined drive leads to The Andretti Estate, featuring 9 bedrooms, 12 bathrooms, 7 fireplaces & surrounded by manicured lawns, wooded trails & sweeping open-water views. Inside, craftsmanship & technology merge seamlessly with integrated automation, a three-level elevator & advanced security enhancing everyday life. The main level unfolds with breathtaking vistas from every gathering space, including a fireside study that leads to the estate lounge with bar, billiards area & sitting rooms. The culinary space showcases dual kitchens: a discreet caterer's kitchen is steps away from the primary, featuring commercial-grade appliances, a 14' island, and seamless flow to a 38' heated veranda with grilling area, retractable screens, and sweeping lake views. An elegant anteroom leads to the private owner's wing with a relaxing reading room & coffee nook. A double-sided fireplace is shared with the primary bedroom, its curved walls framing lake views through a full wall of windows. A spa bath rests beneath a glass-tiled barrel ceiling, while 650 sq ft of closet space completes the suite. The upper level offers two wings, one with a loft & 2 en suite bedrooms, the other a guest wing with kitchen, living room, 2 en suite bedrooms, laundry & garage access. The resort-style walkout level presents a 15-seat bar, 700 bottle wine cellar, theater, arcade, billiards room, fitness studio, 4 bedrooms, 5 baths & 4 exterior exits. The outdoor space features a 50' gunite pool with slide, jacuzzi, waterfalls, fire features, multiple patios, a children's play cottage with HVAC & a 50' three-slip boat dock. A newer carriage house includes two 900 sq ft apartments, each with a kitchen, en suite bedroom, living room, laundry & 2-car garage. 5,500 sq ft of climate-controlled garage space with 12+ bays completes this unparalleled estate.

10606 Brooks School Road, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$349,900
RARE opportunity to buy raw land to build, invest, or develop in extremely desirable Geist. Time to discover the new site to your dream home or investment development on this enchanting 1.73-acre wooded lot nestled within walking distance of Geist Lake, scenic trails, and vibrant dining spots. Embrace the tranquility of nature as you envision your forever home amidst towering trees and serene surroundings but minutes to 96th shops and restaurants. Enjoy leisurely strolls to Geist Lake for boating or simply unwind with picturesque views. Purchase as a land investment. Buy now and develop a landscape for yourself or others. Executive home buyers, builders, developers and investors this land has all the potential in an amazing location!

E 96th Street, Fishers

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative