Shelby County Real Estate

Welcome to Shelby County, Indiana—a hidden gem that beautifully balances small-town charm with modern conveniences. Nestled just a short drive from the bustling city of Indianapolis, Shelby County offers a unique blend of serene landscapes and vibrant community life, making it an ideal place to call home.

With a rich history dating back to its founding in 1821, Shelby County is steeped in tradition and culture. The county seat, Shelbyville, is known for its historic downtown area, where you can stroll along tree-lined streets and explore unique shops, delightful eateries, and local art galleries. The community is friendly and welcoming, with numerous events and festivals throughout the year, including the popular Shelby County Fair, which celebrates the region's agricultural heritage.

Outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to love in Shelby County. The area is dotted with beautiful parks, such as Blue River Memorial Park and the scenic trails of the Mounds State Park, perfect for hiking, biking, and picnicking. With its picturesque landscapes, Shelby County is ideal for those who appreciate nature and outdoor activities.

Families will appreciate the excellent school systems and a strong sense of community that prioritizes education and youth development. The county's affordable housing options make it an attractive destination for first-time homebuyers and growing families.

Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or a place to grow your roots, Shelby County, IN, offers a perfect blend of tranquility and opportunity. Discover your dream home in this vibrant community today!

Newest Listings in Shelby County

$119,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

FIXER UPPER! Cash or hard money only. High ARVs with comps around $300k on same street. Half acre in Triton Schools, amazing proximity to 74, Indy, Shelbyville, and Triton school. This 1,647-square-foot single-family residence, constructed in 1995, stands as a prime investment opportunity for those with a vision to enhance its inherent value. Presented in a ranch-style architectural form, this property offers a substantial 23,522-square-foot lot, providing a generous canvas for a tailored transformation. The interior layout encompasses three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, designed for functional, single-level living. One bathroom provides the convenience of a double vanity, while a walk-in shower serves as a key feature in the bathroom facilities. Completing the residence are practical elements designed for daily efficiency, including a dedicated laundry room and an attached garage. The expansive grounds and the home's foundational design provide an ideal starting point for a thoughtful update, making this a smart acquisition for handy homeowners or investors seeking their next project. Reach out today to schedule your private showing and explore the possibilities this unique Fairland property has to offer.

7303 N Christopher Lane, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Justin Polston. Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass

$174,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Huge Yard!! Discover the charm of 507 S Walnut St in Fairland, IN. Built in 1930, this single-family residence offers 1,216 square feet of living space. The enduring character of this home serves as an excellent foundation for those eager to restore its original appeal. This residence features three bedrooms (2 large and 1 small). The property is situated on a huge lot, offering substantial outdoor space to complement the 1 story home. This generous lot size provides a versatile canvas for landscaping or outdoor activities. Reach out today to schedule your private tour and explore the possibilities of this Fairland residence.

507 S Walnut Street, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Tamara Scroggins. Your Realty Link, LLC

$303,160

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Located at 2263 Bear Oak Run in Shelbyville, this new construction home by M/I Homes offers 1,585 square feet of single-level living. With 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and an open-concept layout, the floorplan is designed to accommodate everyday routines. Additional features include a spacious kitchen island, an upgraded gathering room extension, an electric fireplace, an owner's bedroom with private en-suite bathroom, a 2-car garage, and more! The interior centers on the living space that connects the main gathering areas, allowing natural light to travel through the home and making conversation easy between the kitchen, dining, and living areas. The layout supports both quiet evenings and larger gatherings, with clear sightlines and practical traffic flow throughout. The quality of design is evident in the thoughtful proportions of each room and the attention given to storage, circulation, and natural light. Secondary bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, a home office, or additional living space, while the shared full bathroom serves these rooms conveniently. As a newly built home, the systems, finishes, and materials are brand-new, reducing the immediate maintenance typically associated with older homes and allowing you to move into an energy-efficient home from day one!

2263 Bear Oak Run, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Mencias. M/I Homes of Indiana, L.P.

$342,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Located at 2254 Bear Oak Run in Shelbyville, Indiana, this new construction home offers 2,308 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space across 2 stories. The floorplan balances shared gathering areas with private retreats, making it well suited to a variety of daily routines. Key features of this home include 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a veranda, an electric fireplace, an open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area, a loft, walk-in closets in each bedroom, a 2-car garage, and more! The main level centers on an open-concept living space that connects the kitchen, dining area, and family room. This layout keeps sightlines clear from one room to the next, allowing for easy conversation during meal preparation and comfortable flow when hosting guests. The half bathroom on the main level serves guests, while the 2 full bathrooms upstairs accommodate household members. The owner's bedroom includes its own en-suite bathroom, providing separation from the secondary bedrooms. Construction quality reflects established building standards, with attention to structural details, material selection, and finish work throughout. As a newly built home, the systems, appliances, and surfaces are brand-new.

2254 Bear Oak Run, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Mencias. M/I Homes of Indiana, L.P.

$199,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Step into the timeless character of 608 W South in Shelbyville, Indiana. Built in 1900, this 1,679-square-foot single-family residence seamlessly blends historical charm with a move-in-ready, inviting atmosphere. This 1.5-story home serves as a testament to classic architecture, offering a balanced living space that feels both intimate and spacious. The living room serves as the heart of the home, grounding the space with rich hardwood flooring and a fireplace that anchors the room for quiet evenings. The bedrooms continue the refined aesthetic of the home, each featuring the warmth and durability of hardwood flooring. The 2.5 car garage is a mechanic's or musicians dream. Wood burning stove and engine hoist with all kinds of storage. Beyond the interior, the property offers a variety of functional spaces designed for relaxation and utility. The back porch and patio are a great spot for entertaining and campfire smores.. A classic porch welcomes guests at the entrance, while the basement offers additional space for storage or future potential. This inviting home provides the perfect backdrop for your next chapter, so schedule your private tour today to experience its unique character firsthand.

608 W South, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Christopher Lux. eXp Realty, LLC

$210,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

3 BD, 2 full bath home in the heart of Shelbyville. Close to schools. Owner has put in many updates, including the important mechanicals, like Furnace, AC, Water Heater, and Roof. This home is larger than the listed sq. ft. Owner measures the home at about 1450 sq ft, so don't be surprised that is larger than expected. There is covered parking in front, and also 2 storage barns. This is a lot of house.

726 5th Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Gregory Monfreda. Excel Real Estate, LLC

$149,900

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Bring your vision to this distinctive two-story brick property in Shelbyville. Previously used as a church and daycare, the building offers spacious gathering areas, multiple kitchens, and upstairs living quarters with a kitchen, bathroom, and balcony. Hardwood flooring and a fenced outdoor area add to the property's character and possibilities. Explore how this adaptable layout could serve your plans, subject to verification of zoning, permitted uses, and required approvals.

905 S Pike, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Bryan Rhoads. LKV Realty, LLC

$199,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Introducing 804 W Washington St Shelbyville, IN where comfort and modern updates come together! This newly renovated 2 bedroom / 2 full bath will totally surprise you with its layout and spacious feel. In the heart of the home, you will find a gorgeous, updated kitchen with a new cabinets, appliances, counter tops, and lighting. The backsplash is meant to impress with a stylish herringbone pattern. The island functions for storage AND accommodates for seating. The large dining room can easily hold the family table and side table. The Living room is located at the front of the home and has a large window just waiting for a Christmas tree! The primary bedroom has ample space and its own private bathroom with standup shower. The second bedroom is located towards the back of the home right off the guest bathroom. The guest bathroom has been completely updated with shower stall, toilet and vanity. The laundry room completes this ranch style home. The detached garage and covered "carport" style can accommodate 2 vehicles. The garage has electric, automatic garage door, concrete floors and a service door. Partial fencing adds to your privacy on this corner lot property. Brand new roof on the house and garage add to the many new items including all new flooring and water heater. Don't miss out on this special home and all of the updates it has to offer.

804 W Washington Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Christie Mclaughlin. Maximum Results Real Estate

$294,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

A little piece of the country, with room to gather inside and out! Set on two lots totaling 0.84 acre, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offers mature trees, beautiful sunsets, and a peaceful setting. The level yard has room for outdoor games, while the firepit invites crisp evenings roasting s'mores beneath the stars. A covered front porch and open patio offer more places to enjoy the outdoors, and a storage barn keeps equipment and extras tucked away. Inside, thoughtful updates add character and a cozy feel to 1,702 square feet of single-level living. The updated eat-in kitchen provides space for everyday meals and holiday baking, while separate living and family rooms give you options for gathering or spreading out. The spacious family room off the kitchen offers flexibility for hosting, hobbies, play, or overnight guests. An attached two-car garage rounds out the home. Enjoy the breathing room of a country setting with Shelbyville's shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences nearby. This must be the place!

2581 E McKay Road, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Joseph Bontrager. 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate

$574,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

COUNTRY LIVING AT ITS FINEST! 3.45 ACRES, RENOVATED FARMHOUSE, INGROUND POOL & INCREDIBLE MORTON BUILDING! This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath farmhouse offers 2,882 sq. ft. of living space, blending timeless charm with modern comforts! Originally built in 1900, the home was taken down to the studs and extensively renovated in 2008, then lovingly maintained year after year. Step inside to warm, inviting living spaces and a beautifully updated kitchen featuring a premium Wolf stove, Cafe refrigerator and dishwasher. Upstairs, the impressive 26x26 primary suite offers a spacious retreat, complemented by two additional bedrooms and new carpet. The family room features updated vinyl flooring, while smart switches add convenience to the dining room. Need room for vehicles, hobbies or projects? You'll LOVE the oversized 27x31 two-car garage with 10-ft. ceilings, EV charger and whole-house surge protection at the electrical panel! The real SHOWSTOPPER is the 2019 MORTON BUILDING! Fully insulated, heated and cooled, featuring epoxy floors, 110/220 power, smart switches and plugs, plus double pass-through garage doors! Outside, your COUNTRY OASIS awaits! Enjoy summer days around the inground pool with NEW liner and cover, concrete patio and poolside pergola. Relax on the west-facing porch while taking in beautiful sunsets, tend to the raised garden beds or enjoy the chicken coop. With 3.45 acres, there's room to spread out and embrace the country lifestyle! MORE THAN A HOME-IT'S A LIFESTYLE! This remarkable Fountaintown property offers charm, modern conveniences and exceptional space for living, entertaining and all your hobbies. Come see what makes this one so special!

6744 W 1100 N, Fountaintown

Listing courtesy of Rhonda Krebs. CENTURY 21 Scheetz

$349,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover this one-of-a-kind riverfront property offering a rare blend of history, character, modern comfort, and natural beauty. Tucked away in a private rural setting, this distinctive home features remnants of an 1823 water-powered river mill and an extraordinary original 35-foot hand-hewn timber beam showcased in the impressive 14-foot vaulted great room. Completely reconstructed in March 2023, with less than 10% of the original 1950s walls and ceiling remaining, the home features extensive improvements, including a new metal roof, plumbing, electrical, septic system, well pump, HVAC, furnace, siding, gutters, water treatment system, gas water heater, appliances, fireplace, and front and rear decking. Additional quality details include 2x6 exterior walls, insulated interior walls, extensive closed-cell spray foam insulation, and a fully encapsulated crawlspace. May 2026 brought new triple-pane windows with a lifetime transferable warranty. The inviting open-concept interior combines warm finishes, exposed timber, and a beautiful stone fireplace. Offering approximately 1,900 SF of main living space plus a 12x20 bonus room, the home also features 36-inch doors throughout and an ADA ramp for added accessibility. Enjoy peaceful river and Zen garden views from every bedroom, or unwind on the deck surrounded by nature. Seller is also offering the option to purchase a private 10 acres island directly behind the house. Two additional outbuildings provide useful storage or hobby space: a 10x16 wood building and a 12x20 metal building. With its fascinating history, distinctive craftsmanship, extensive reconstruction, accessibility features, and private riverfront setting, this is more than a home-it's a truly special place to call your own! Some homes are simply different. This one has a story to tell! Come check it out today.

9204 N 300 E, Morristown

Listing courtesy of Camelia Cucuruz. Runnebohm Realty, LLC

$214,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Welcome to 618 Berkeley Dr., Shelbyville, IN! This charming 1960 ranch-style home offers 1,212 square feet of comfortable, move-in-ready living space with a blend of classic character and modern updates. Step inside to discover new hardwood laminate flooring throughout most of the home, creating a fresh, updated look that carries throughout the living spaces. The inviting living room features a vaulted ceiling that adds an open, airy feel, along with a cozy fireplace that makes the perfect centerpiece for relaxing evenings or entertaining guests. The kitchen is equipped with modern stainless steel appliances, offering both style and functionality for everyday living. The spacious bathroom features a large double vanity, providing added convenience and plenty of room for busy mornings. Outside, enjoy the private backyard and patio, perfect for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply relaxing and enjoying the sunshine. Situated on a 7,140-square-foot lot, this property offers a manageable outdoor space with plenty of possibilities. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, downsizing, or simply looking for a comfortable home with updates already in place, this property is worth a look! Don't miss your opportunity to make 618 Berkeley Dr. your next home. Schedule your private showing today!

618 Berkeley Drive, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Matthew Worton. Your Realty Link, LLC

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.

Shelby County Real Estate

Newest Listings in Shelby County

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?