Shelbyville Homes with Cellar Basement

Shelbyville Homes with Cellar Basement

Welcome to Shelbyville, Indiana – a charming city that beautifully blends small-town warmth with vibrant community spirit. Nestled in Shelby County, Shelbyville boasts a rich history, picturesque landscapes, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes it a perfect place to call home.

Known for its friendly neighborhoods, Shelbyville offers a diverse selection of homes that cater to various lifestyles. Among these, you’ll find an intriguing feature that sets many properties apart: cellar basements. These unique spaces not only provide additional storage but can also be transformed into cozy retreats, workshops, or recreational areas. Imagine having a cool, quiet cellar where you can escape the hustle and bustle, or a space to host family gatherings and game nights.

The city’s strategic location, just a short drive from Indianapolis, allows residents to enjoy the best of both worlds. You can relish the tranquility of suburban life while having easy access to the cultural and economic opportunities of a major city. Shelbyville is also known for its excellent schools, parks, and community events, making it an ideal choice for families and individuals alike.

As you explore the real estate market in Shelbyville, you’ll find homes with cellar basements that not only offer practicality but also a touch of character. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or looking to upgrade, Shelbyville is a place where you can truly settle down and create lasting memories. Discover your dream home in this delightful city and embrace the lifestyle you've always wanted!

Newest Shelbyville Homes with Cellar Basement

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Rustic charm meets city convenience in this character-filled 1900 home! Offering 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 1,112 square feet, this home features original hardwood floors in the primary bedroom, living room, and formal dining room, showcasing its timeless appeal. Major updates include a new HVAC system (2023) and a new roof (2025), providing peace of mind for years to come. The home could use a little TLC, making it a great opportunity to add your personal style while preserving its historic character. Enjoy the convenience of off-street parking located at the rear of the home. Whether you're a first-time buyer, investor, or someone who appreciates vintage charm, this home offers endless potential in a convenient city location.

609 Montgomery Street, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover a unique opportunity for immediate equity! This large formal traditional American home has been cared for but is ready for some new life to be breathed into the interior with some fresh cosmetics. It is a great starter home and you can move right in! An absolute gem of a back yard gives you privacy and your personal oasis of stocked coy pond (two of them) accented with Tennessee flag stone. This inviting 3-4 Bedroom/2 Full bath residence, built in 1900, offers 1828 square feet of comfortable living space, ready for you to move in and make it your own. The home features four generous bedrooms, providing ample private retreats for all. One of the two full bathrooms presents a spacious layout. Beyond the interiors, the exterior welcomes you with a charming porch, perfect for enjoying quiet mornings or peaceful evenings. The private yard offers an intimate outdoor space for relaxation or recreation. Embrace the blend of historic charm and modern comfort this two-story residence offers.

236 E Pennsylvania, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Mackenzie Allen, Polston & Ass.

investment special. Live in one side and rent out the other. Current owner lives in one side and rents out the other side for $635/month. Owner pays water, sewer, trash, and lawn. Seperate gas and electric meters. Two furnaces, and two water heaters. AC in the buidling is currently not working, but it is installed. Main unit has kitchen that has been recently updated. Home has PEX plumbing and recent roof, gutters and downspouts due to hail claim. Property to be sold as-is.

219 W Locust, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Runnebohm Realty, LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Todd Messer - Owner | Broker

Todd Messer is the driving force behind Indiana Home Realty — a trusted real estate professional known for his straight-forward approach, strong market knowledge, and commitment to serving clients the right way. Born and raised in Indiana, Todd understands the communities he represents because he has lived, worked, and built relationships here his entire life. With years of hands-on experience in residential real estate, Todd leads with a blend of old-school work ethic and modern strategy. He believes every client deserves honesty, clear communication, and a dependable guide who keeps the process moving from start to finish. Whether it’s preparing a home for market, negotiating on behalf of a buyer, or navigating the details behind the scenes, Todd treats every transaction like it’s his own. What sets Todd apart is his ability to make people feel taken care of. Clients often describe him as steady, reliable, and the person they trust to keep things on track when it matters most. He has built Indiana Home Realty into a team that reflects those same values — experienced agents who put relationships first and make clients feel like part of a family, not just a file. Outside of real estate, Todd is heavily involved in the community. From supporting local events to running a small business, he believes in giving back and staying connected to the people who make Indiana feel like home.

Learn More