Shelby Homes for Sale

Shelby Homes for Sale

Welcome to Shelby, Indiana – a hidden gem that beautifully blends small-town charm with modern conveniences. Nestled in the heart of the Hoosier State, Shelby offers a warm and inviting community that is perfect for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With its picturesque landscapes, friendly neighbors, and rich history, it's no wonder that Shelby is becoming a sought-after destination for homebuyers.

The region boasts a variety of outdoor recreational opportunities, including parks, walking trails, and nearby lakes, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts. The local economy is thriving, supported by a mix of small businesses and larger enterprises, ensuring that residents have access to essential services and employment opportunities. Shelby also prides itself on its excellent schools, making it an ideal place to raise a family.

When it comes to real estate, Shelby has something for everyone. Whether you’re searching for a cozy starter home, a spacious family residence, or a charming historic property, the homes for sale in this area cater to diverse tastes and budgets. Many properties feature lovely yards, modern amenities, and easy access to local attractions.

With a strong sense of community, vibrant local events, and a welcoming atmosphere, Shelby is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to call home. Explore the available homes for sale today and discover the perfect property that fits your lifestyle in this delightful Indiana town. Your dream home in Shelby awaits!

Newest Shelby Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Investor opportunity! Situated on a 1.85-acre corner lot, this property offers outstanding potential for renovation, rental income, or future development. The property includes a 40' x 30' pole barn with a concrete floor and electricity, providing excellent storage or workshop space. The home is in need of repairs and is ready for your vision. Sold AS IS. Seller makes no warranties, expressed or implied.

8038 S Us 421, Madison

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Martin Miller Lamb.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Country living at its best right outside of city limits! This beautifully maintained brick ranch has 3 bedrooms, office, 2 full baths and 1 half bath. Large living room with hardwood flooring over looks a peaceful country view. Updated kitchen has new granite, 5 yr old refrigerator and stove, 1 yr old dishwasher and new flooring. Dining room has gas fireplace. Lovely covered patio off of the dining and kitchen offer a private oasis to sit and relax or entertain. Split bedroom floor plan offers primary and office, half and full bath on one side and 2 bedrooms and full bath on the other. One bedroom is currently used as a den. There is a 3 car attached garage and a separate garage/workshop. Roof is only 4-5 yrs old. Pella windows were installed approximately 10 years ago. Back yard is fenced, but the property goes beyond the fencing. Property sits on .84 of an acre. You will absolutely love this home!

313 E 275 S, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Hoosier, REALTORS®.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2 full-bath home offering the perfect blend of style, comfort, and flexibility. In addition to the three bedrooms, you'll love the bonus room-perfect for a home office, playroom, media room, or guest space. The open-concept layout is designed for everyday living and entertaining, featuring a spacious kitchen with rich cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, a center island with seating, a pantry, stylish tile backsplash, and modern lighting. The inviting living room is anchored by a cozy electric fireplace with custom built-in bookshelves, creating the perfect place to gather. The private primary suite features a walk-in closet and an updated en-suite bath with a beautifully tiled walk-in shower. Step outside to an incredible backyard designed for making memories. A huge gazebo spans the back patio, creating the perfect space for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply relaxing. Gather around the fire pit on cool evenings and enjoy the spacious yard with plenty of room for kids, pets, and gardening. Move-in ready and thoughtfully updated throughout, this home offers the space, features, and outdoor living you've been looking for. Schedule your private showing today!

703 S Kerkhoff Avenue, Otterbein

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Discover the allure of country living at 2513 W 300 S, Shelbyville, IN. This inviting single-family stone ranch, built in 1958, offers a generous living space and is ready for you to move in. This updated ranch-style home features 4 large bedrooms, providing ample private retreats. With recently remodeled 2.5 bathrooms, daily routines are effortlessly accommodated. Enjoy the openness of the kitchen and family room for all of your gatherings. The convenience of a single-story layout enhances the flow and accessibility of the entire home. Wonderful closet and storage space. Set on a substantial 3+ acres, this property offers considerable outdoor space for various activities. An attached garage provides secure parking and additional storage. This property also offers a large versatile barn with a loft. There is also a pond on the property. So much to offer. New (2024) 5 finger septic system and a perimeter drain offer peace of mind. Explore the possibilities of making this delightful property your own. This home is located in the Shelbyville School District but also very close to the Southwestern School District. New barn roof 6/2026.

2513 W 300 S, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of The Stewart Home Group.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Better than new and only one owner! Easy living main level with loft is hard to find! This beautiful home offers spacious main-level w/Open Concept layout perfect for everyday life and entertaining. The oversized loft is ideal for a game room, workout area, 2nd living space, playroom, home offices or added bedrooms. Featuring generously sized rooms, dedicated laundry room, flex spaces including a 7x7 space perfect for an office, workshop, hobby room or extra storage. Modern, functional, and move in ready... this one checks ALL the boxes!

1234 Breckinridge Way, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Runnebohm Realty, LLC.

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

PRICE DROPPED, Ready for an offer!! What a great home without an HOA, great backyard with peace and tranquility, just ready for your personal updates inside. This ready-to-move-in single-family residence, built in 1964, offers 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath, 1656 square feet of comfortable living space, designed for effortless living. The heart of this home is its thoughtfully appointed kitchen, featuring a practical peninsula, and stylish accents including a wainscot wall and a wood wall. It is equipped with matching black appliances, ensuring a cohesive and contemporary feel. Relax and refresh in the bathroom, which provides a convenient walk-in shower. This charming ranch-style home also includes a dedicated laundry room for daily convenience and washer and dryer stays with the house, an attached garage for ease of access, and a covered deck, perfect for outdoor enjoyment. Will not be approved for FHA and being sold AS-IS.

1225 E Hazelwood Street S, Shelbyville

Listing courtesy of Hoosier, REALTORS®.

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Cozy Country Living on 8 Acres - 4BR Home with Pond & Outbuilding Welcome to your peaceful retreat in the heart of Ripley County! Nestled along 250 South in Versailles, this charming 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern updates and serene country living. Set on a quiet and picturesque 8-acre lot, the property features a mix of timber-including some mature trees-ideal for nature lovers, hunters, or those just seeking tranquility. A fully stocked pond adds to the beauty and functionality of the land, making it a great spot to relax or fish. Step inside to find a warm and welcoming home with fresh paint throughout and brand-new appliances that stay. The newly installed standing seam metal roof not only adds durability but enhances the home's curb appeal, complemented by attractive new landscaping and stone walkways. Outside, a spacious detached garage/workshop with overhead door provides space for hobbies, projects, or storage. Utilities are ready to go with electric and water on site, and high-speed fiber internet available at the road-perfect for working from home or streaming your favorite shows. Whether you are looking for a quiet homestead, a weekend getaway, or a place to enjoy the outdoors and wildlife, this property is a rare find in a beautiful setting. Don't miss your chance to own a slice of country paradise-schedule your showing today!

3263 W County Road 250 S, Versailles

Listing courtesy of Mossy Oak Properties.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Todd Messer - Owner | Broker

Todd Messer is the driving force behind Indiana Home Realty — a trusted real estate professional known for his straight-forward approach, strong market knowledge, and commitment to serving clients the right way. Born and raised in Indiana, Todd understands the communities he represents because he has lived, worked, and built relationships here his entire life. With years of hands-on experience in residential real estate, Todd leads with a blend of old-school work ethic and modern strategy. He believes every client deserves honesty, clear communication, and a dependable guide who keeps the process moving from start to finish. Whether it’s preparing a home for market, negotiating on behalf of a buyer, or navigating the details behind the scenes, Todd treats every transaction like it’s his own. What sets Todd apart is his ability to make people feel taken care of. Clients often describe him as steady, reliable, and the person they trust to keep things on track when it matters most. He has built Indiana Home Realty into a team that reflects those same values — experienced agents who put relationships first and make clients feel like part of a family, not just a file. Outside of real estate, Todd is heavily involved in the community. From supporting local events to running a small business, he believes in giving back and staying connected to the people who make Indiana feel like home.

Learn More