Sugar Creek Homes with Rural - Not Subdivision Lot features

Sugar Creek Homes with Rural - Not Subdivision Lot features

Welcome to Sugar Creek, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Midwest. This charming community offers a unique blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences, making it an ideal place for those seeking a serene lifestyle without sacrificing accessibility. With its picturesque landscapes, Sugar Creek is a haven for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

One of the standout features of Sugar Creek is its abundance of homes situated on spacious rural lots, free from the constraints of traditional subdivisions. Here, you’ll find properties that boast expansive yards, lush greenery, and breathtaking views of the surrounding countryside. Whether you’re looking for a cozy farmhouse or a contemporary retreat, the homes in this area provide ample space for gardening, outdoor activities, and enjoying the beauty of nature right outside your door.

In addition to its stunning homes, Sugar Creek is conveniently located near major highways, making it easy to access nearby cities for shopping, dining, and entertainment. The community is also known for its friendly atmosphere, where neighbors become friends and local events bring everyone together.

For families, Sugar Creek offers excellent schools and safe neighborhoods, making it a fantastic place to raise children. With a rich history and a strong sense of community, Sugar Creek invites you to explore its charming streets and discover the perfect home that fits your rural lifestyle. Come experience the warmth and beauty of Sugar Creek, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes with Rural - Not Subdivision Lot features

$1,700,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Private 12-acre estate, no HOA, zoned Ag/Livestock - just 20 min to downtown Indy & 30 min to the airport! This 4BR, 3 full/2 half BA, 4,879 sq ft home (built 2002) impresses w/ copper roof, dramatic 2-story foyer & great room, and solid cherry hardwoods across the main level. Open-concept kitchen boasts leathered granite, Sub-Zero & stainless appliances & large pantry. Luxurious primary suite w/ spacious walk-in shower, custom cabinetry & walk-in closet; 2 add'l bedrooms & bonus room up; finished basement w/ exercise room/bedroom & playroom. Resort-style grounds: salt-cell in-ground pool w/ new auto cover & app-controlled lights, copper-roofed pavilion w/ full outdoor kitchen, fireplace, hot/cold water & TV, plus fully stocked 1/2+ acre pond (18-25 ft deep) & free wireless internet via 100-ft tower. 3 outbuildings: 2,800 sq ft 2-story metal bldg w/ heat/AC, full kitchen & bath, W/D & dog bath - ideal in-law/guest/office - plus 40x40 garage; 2,000 sq ft 4-stall horse barn w/ tack room, heated concrete floor & 14-ft door for indoor RV parking; 36x42 workshop w/ lean-to, wood stove & 220 service. Acres of fenced pasture. Land, luxury & location - a rare find!

7504 W 600 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mossy Oak Properties.

$284,000
It's the building site that you have dreamed of - just East of New Palestine and South of US 52 on County Road 400 West. Two magnificent 5.68 Acre lots, partially wooded setting in the country. All the conveniences, schools, medical and shopping just less than 2 miles away. Sold individually and ready for immediate possession

5850 S 400 W, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Group.

$284,000
It's the building site that you have dreamed of - just East of New Palestine and South of US 52 on County Road 400 West. Two magnificent 5.68 Acre lots, partially wooded setting in the country. All the conveniences, schools, medical and shopping just less than 2 miles away. Sold individually and ready for immediate possession.

5800 S 400 W, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Realty Group.

$389,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Beautifully maintained two-story brick home offering 1,910 square feet with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an oversized two-car garage, all situated on 2 picturesque acres in the desirable Southern Hancock School District. Inside, you'll find hardwood floors throughout and a bright, inviting sunroom overlooking the peaceful backyard and mature trees. The kitchen comes complete with all appliances, including a newer refrigerator, making this home move-in ready from day one. Lovingly cared for over the years, this well-built home offers exceptional bones and provides the perfect opportunity for a new owner to add their own style and cosmetic updates over time. Whether you choose to make a few updates or renovate to your taste, this property offers endless potential. Outside, you'll appreciate the flexibility of two outbuildings, one with electricity, making it ideal for a workshop, hobby space, additional storage, or other projects. The oversized two-car garage provides plenty of room for vehicles and extra storage. With no HOA, you'll enjoy the freedom to make the most of your property. Walking distance to the Pennsy trail. Situated on a beautiful two-acre lot with mature trees, this property offers the peace of country living while remaining conveniently located. If you're searching for space, privacy, solid construction, and the opportunity to make a home your own, this property is one you won't want to miss!

6084 W 100 S. S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of BluPrint Real Estate Group.

$350,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Enjoy peaceful country living on 1.5 acres with no HOA restrictions. This well-maintained home features 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, offering plenty of space for family and guests. The spacious kitchen includes a large 50" x 106" island, perfect for meal prep, entertaining, or casual dining. Recent updates include newer flooring throughout (no carpet) and fresh interior paint, making this home move-in ready. Step outside and relax on the 16' x 16' wood deck or enjoy your morning coffee on the full-length covered front porch that stretches across the front of the home. An oversized two-car garage provides ample space for vehicles, storage, or a workshop.

4735 S 800 W, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$549,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to country living with room to spread out without giving up the convenience of being in town. Situated on 5.36 total acres, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home delivers a rare combination of comfortable living space, functional outbuildings, and acreage. The open concept layout features spacious living and gathering areas, a warm brick fireplace with built-ins, and a kitchen and dining area designed for everyday living and entertaining. Large windows and rear access create seamless views of the surrounding property. Outside is where this property truly shines. The front parcel offers in-town convenience, while the rear acreage extends into the county, providing added flexibility and privacy. The impressive 40x56 pole barn is built to work with 14-foot sidewalls, 12-foot overhead doors, concrete floors with floor drain, 200-amp electrical service, water hookup, an 8x16 covered porch, and a 40x18 lean-to is ideal for equipment storage, hobbies, livestock, or workshop use. The property also includes fenced pasture, making it ready for animals or hobby farming.

528 N Pearl Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

$4,187,500
Discover an exceptional mix of productive farmland and prime recreational woodland in the heart of Parke County. This 335-acre +/- property features approximately 200 acres of tillable ground and a beautiful balance of mature woods. The southern portion boasts 1.3 miles of direct frontage along scenic Sugar Creek, creating a stunning natural boundary and endless opportunities for kayaking, canoeing, fishing, and wildlife viewing. A few barns and a couple of silos provide functional infrastructure for agricultural operations. Income-Producing & Turn-Key Opportunity. Currently leased to a reliable farmer, this property generates steady income while you enjoy the benefits of ownership. The productive tillable acres make it an attractive investment for those seeking agricultural returns alongside long-term appreciation while enjoying this Premier Recreational Paradise. Nestled near Turkey Run State Park and not far from the historic Narrows Covered Bridge, the property sits in one of Indiana's most beloved outdoor destinations. Renowned for monster bucks, making it a dream for serious whitetail hunters. Parke has a long history of producing big bucks. It ranks among the top Indiana counties in Pope & Young (P&Y) record-book entries for bow-killed whitetails historically #1. Whether you're kayaking along Sugar Creek, exploring trails, or setting up a private hunting camp, this land delivers year-round enjoyment for the whole family. This rare combination of productive farmland, income potential, and world-class recreation in a high-demand area won't last long. Ideal for the savvy investor, multi-generational family retreat, or passionate outdoorsman looking to own a piece of Parke County's natural beauty. Contact us today for more details or to schedule a private showing of this outstanding Sugar Creek property! Property can only be shown with proof of qualified buyers.

9019 N Henley Road, Marshall

Listing courtesy of Legacy Land & Homes of Indiana.

$429,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to your own piece of Indiana paradise! Not just a secluded home but this 1.23 acres features woods, a creek running thru it, a landing down by the creek for RVs, friends, camping, etc. All this just 2 miles from DT New Pal. The house? Renovated completely down to the studs and all new except for the beautifully refinished hardwood floors. Your all new kitchen features SS appliances, granite counters, and a center island w/ breakfast bar. The dining area in the country kitchen has a view of the woods, leads to the oversize pantry/laundry area and the new back deck. A large MBR includes an office or sitting area, 3 closets. Your custom bath has a 5 ft tiled, walk-in shower, double vanity. Hall bath is just as custom and gorgeous. When Dad sees the garage/Morton barn he'll love it. 984 sf -room for 8+ cars or store your big boy toys, equipment or run a business in here. There's also a separate shed in the back yard for Mom. Come to see the views and deer, stay for the peaceful feeling you get here. Don't miss this one!

3862 W 400 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of BluPrint Real Estate Group.

$1,950,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths
Stunning 10 Acre Estate on Snail Creek in Fairland, IN. Located 35 minutes from downtown Indianapolis. Discover unparalleled luxury and tranquility in this estate located over 1/4 mile off the county road. Perfectly blending modern amenities with natural beauty for an exceptional retreat for those seeking both comfort and adventure. Property features a beautifully landscaped lawn and lush woods offering privacy and natural beauty. Spacious living with over 10,000 square feet of living space with six bedrooms, four full baths, two 1/2 baths, two laundry rooms and mud room off of the main floor garage. The home office and sunroom on the main floor add versatility and comfort to the living space. The large gourmet kitchen with a walk in pantry provides ample space for cooking and storage. The home theater, indoor racquetball room and a basement recreation area are perfect for gatherings and entertaining. For outside activities you can enjoy a basketball court and tennis court. There are two play cabins with lofts and a fenced backyard with a redwood playground for children to play outdoors safely. There are two storage rooms, a seven car garage and heated garage area. Enjoy the warmth of three fireplaces, a wraparound porch and covered back porch for relaxation and enjoying the views. The home was recently updated with new geothermal furnaces, new roof and new water heater. The property also has walking trails and scenic views including a small apple orchard. This property is a rare find offering a unique combination of luxury, functionality and natural beauty in a picturesque setting. Whether you're looking for a serene escape or an entertainer's paradise, this estate has it all. (Additional acreage is available for purchase.)

3917 N 525 W, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Vintage Realty, Inc..

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative