Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

**Discover the Charm of Sugar Creek, Indiana: Your Ideal Home Awaits!**

Nestled in the heart of Indiana, Sugar Creek is a hidden gem that beautifully blends small-town charm with modern conveniences. This picturesque community is known for its lush landscapes, friendly neighborhoods, and a strong sense of community spirit. Whether you're seeking a quiet retreat or a place to raise a family, Sugar Creek offers a welcoming atmosphere that makes everyone feel at home.

One of the highlights of living in Sugar Creek is its accessibility to major cities. Just a short drive from Indianapolis, residents can enjoy the vibrant city life while returning to the tranquility of their suburban haven. The area boasts excellent schools, beautiful parks, and a variety of recreational activities, making it an ideal location for families and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

When it comes to homes for sale, Sugar Creek has something to suit every taste and budget. From charming single-family homes with sprawling yards to modern townhouses, the real estate market here is diverse and inviting. Many properties feature beautiful architectural details, spacious layouts, and stunning outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or relaxing after a long day.

With a strong sense of community and a wealth of amenities, Sugar Creek is more than just a place to live—it's a place to thrive. If you're considering a move, explore the homes for sale in this delightful region and discover the perfect setting for your next chapter. Your dream home in Sugar Creek awaits!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

$140,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

OPPORTUNITY! 5 acres in North Montgomery School System. This property is just waiting for the right family to make it their very own. *** home is not habitable as it sits, needs major renovation*** Pole barn is in average condition. **Seller is unsure if the well and septic are functional***

7604 N 1000 E, Darlington

Listing courtesy of Danielle Robinson. F.C. Tucker Company

$369,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Stone on the outside, new on the inside. This Brier Creek ranch has a 2026 roof and HVAC, along with a new water heater, windows, garage door, entry doors, ductwork and crawl space vapor barrier. The kitchen is all new, from the cabinetry and solid surface counters to the appliances, and both bathrooms are new top to bottom. Everything lives on one level. Start the morning in the 34 foot sun room, spread out between the family room and a great room with a fireplace, and close the office door when work calls. Out back is more than half an acre of mature trees, a patio and a fire pit for the nights nobody wants to go inside. No HOA. Southern Hancock schools. All the character of an established street, none of the to do list. Seller, through a local surveyor, has applied to FEMA for a Letter of Map Amendment to remove the home structure from the flood zone, and approval is pending. Documentation can be provided upon request.

1281 Fox Trail Drive E, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ryan Cox. BluPrint Real Estate Group

$445,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome home to an elevated lifestyle at The Preserve! This one-of-a-kind Wingate floor plan is the only one in the neighborhood, offering thoughtful upgrades, a more functional layout, and exceptional space and storage throughout. This 3-bed, 3-bath detached home features engineered hardwood flooring throughout, with tile in the bathrooms, laundry room, and sunroom. The open-concept main level showcases crown molding and an expanded kitchen with a large island seating four, soft-close Shaker cabinetry with pull-out shelves, under-cabinet lighting, subway tile backsplash, granite countertops, and stainless appliances, including a double oven with convection. A Kinetico reverse osmosis system is also included! The dining area flows seamlessly into the great room, while the sunroom offers peaceful tree-lined backyard views and French doors leading to the composite deck-perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The main-level split-bedroom floorplan offers privacy with the primary suite tucked away from the front bedroom. It features a tiled walk-in shower, dual vanity, and customized walk-in closet system. The front bedroom also makes an ideal home office, thanks to the additional 3rd bedroom, sitting area and bathroom upstairs... perfect for visitors! Life at The Preserve offers so much more than low-maintenance living. Residents enjoy an impressive collection of community amenities, including a clubhouse with a large gathering space, full kitchen, fitness center, game room, patio with grills and fireplace, and an inviting in-ground pool. And the location? Just a quick golf cart ride to downtown New Palestine, where you can enjoy local shops, restaurants and community festivities! Come see why the preserve might be the perfect place to call home!

4295 W Hidden Preserve, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Sarah O'Donnell. F.C. Tucker Company

$449,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 3394 S. Bennett Drive! Located in New Palestine, Indiana and built in 2013, this 2,500-square-foot home sits on a premium lot in the Stone Crossing Community. The property gifts its owner space, numerous recent updates, and a backyard built for entertaining and some splashing. The main level features a foyer, home office with custom double doors (2023), living room with fireplace, and kitchen with granite countertops, center island, double ovens, and appliances updated in 2019! The primary suite includes a double vanity and soaking tub. Recent improvements include updated main-level flooring, bathroom flooring (2022), refreshed kitchen cabinets and hardware, wooden blinds throughout, and new carpet (2026). Step outside to enjoy a heated swimming pool installed in 2023 with an automatic pool cover, patio canopy (2025), and new landscaping with privacy trees and lighting (2026). The three-car garage includes shelving and additional enclosed storage for those holiday props and landscaping essentials we all need. In New Palestine, residents enjoy small-town living with access to parks, walking and biking trails, local restaurants, and community events, all within a convenient drive to Downtown Indianapolis. Schedule your showing today!

3394 S Bennett Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mike Scott. Scott Estates

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome to small-town living at its finest in the heart of Thorntown! Set on one of town's most desirable residential streets, just blocks from Main Street and the school, this charming home puts everyday conveniences within easy walking distance. Mature trees frame the front yard, while a full-width covered porch is the perfect spot to watch the world go by. The spacious corner lot features a large picket-fenced backyard, covered rear porch, storage shed, and oversized detached 3+ car garage with electricity, abundant storage, and side-street access. A generous parking pad and deck with entrance on side of house offers additional functionality. Inside, a beautiful staircase, large front window, and original hardwood floors in the living and dining rooms showcase the home's character. The bright kitchen features stainless steel appliances, a gas range, and a huge walk-in pantry with freestanding freezer. A cozy breakfast room overlooks the backyard and opens to the rear porch. The expansive family room offers a wet bar with beverage fridge, sliding doors to the backyard, and a half bath, ideal for gathering and entertaining. A unique three-level split layout places the primary bedroom and generous closet between the main and upper floors for added privacy. Upstairs are two more bedrooms and a spacious full bath, complete with jetted tub, walk-in shower, and convenient laundry area. Don't miss the charming gabled window at the top of the stairs, framing views of the tree-lined street. With a newer roof and furnace, generous space, and timeless details, this home is ready for a fresh vision. The price reflects the cosmetic updates needed, offering a wonderful opportunity to make this special home your own in an unbeatable small-town setting! SPECIAL FINANCING: 2/1 temporary rate buydown lowers buyer's rate 2% in year one and 1% in year two. Buyer may use any lender for offer acceptance, but must use Mark Kuchik, CrossCountry Mortgage, for buydown. NMLS139563.

225 S Market Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Angela Delise. Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

$375,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

An island kitchen, connected living and dining areas, and a separate office give 2282 S Bingham Pl a flexible main-level layout. Glass-paneled office doors provide separation from the foyer, while the kitchen has ample cabinetry, a gas range and views across the rear living space. A main-floor bedroom and full bathroom add another option beyond the upstairs rooms. The broad upper-level loft creates a second gathering area. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and an adjoining bathroom with double sinks and a glass-enclosed shower. A patio opens to the fully fenced backyard, and the attached two-car garage completes this two-story New Palestine home. Included 100-Day Home Warranty with buyer activation

2282 S Bingham Place, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Shelby Farrar. Opendoor Brokerage LLC

$425,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome home to 4541 W Rising Sun Dr! From the moment you step inside, this beautifully updated home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and everyday luxury. Cook and entertain with ease in the updated kitchen, or set the mood throughout the entire home-and garage!-with the built-in whole-house audio system. Outside, your private backyard retreat awaits, complete with a lush green lawn nurtured by the irrigation system and a cozy patio with a built-in gas fire pit-the ultimate spot for evening relaxation or unwinding with friends under the stars. Peace of mind comes built-in with an integrated security system featuring outdoor cameras. Every detail has been crafted for comfortable, seamless living-all that's left to do is move in! (Note: Washer and dryer are excluded).

4541 W Rising Sun Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Antwon Culbreath. Redfin Corporation

$299,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome to The Havens subdivision! Here you will find a charming 1500+ sqft home beautifully decorated in warm colors to welcome you home! This property has 3 bedrooms. 2 full bathroom and a open concept set up. From the entry you are immediately drawn in to the spacious living room with vaulted ceilings. The living room is open to the kitchen area and well-appointed dining area. With additional seating at the breakfast bar entertaining guests from the kitchen is super easy! Updated stainless steel appliances and ample countertop space will help bring out your inner culinary artistry. From the living room you are immediately drawn to the extended patio area with glass patio doors overlooking the pond and back yard. Makes for a perfect spot for morning coffee or and evening glass of vino! 2 apples tree are in the back yard along with a storage shed. Back inside the primary bedroom is of spacious size and has access to the patio. The large primary ensuite is light, airy and spa like with plenty of CLOSET SPACE! In addition to all of these details this home offers a 2-car attached garage and a separate laundry room. Being a part of The Havens gives you access to the community pool, tennis courts, basketball court, park and play area, and fishing in any of the ponds. This property has one of the best views overlooking the pond. You don't want to miss it!

4352 W Summerhaven Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Christie Mclaughlin. Maximum Results Real Estate

$629,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to 214 Yorkshire Blvd! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-story home with a finished basement offers the perfect combination of comfortable living and incredible entertaining space. Inside, enjoy hardwood flooring, a remodeled kitchen, a stunning primary bath, a spacious upstairs bonus room, and a sunroom overlooking the backyard. Step outside to an amazing outdoor retreat featuring an expansive double lot with direct access to the Pennsy Trail, a sparkling saltwater pool, fire pit, gazebo, and dedicated bar area. Whether you're hosting summer gatherings or enjoying a quiet evening outdoors, this backyard has it all! Recent updates include a newer roof, furnace and air system, windows, water softener, remodeled kitchen and primary bath, and enhanced landscaping. Located in the award-winning New Palestine school district, this home offers a rare opportunity to enjoy space, style, and an exceptional outdoor lifestyle!

214 Yorkshire Boulevard W, Indianapolis

Listing courtesy of Noah Harris. F.C. Tucker Company

$245,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Solid 2-Story Home on Nice Corner Lot in Thorntown! This two-story traditional home offers a spacious 1,836 square feet of living space with an exceptional 5 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Situated on a nice 0.24-acre corner lot with mature trees and an attached 2-car garage, the property provides a fantastic layout ready for your creative vision and sweat equity. Bring your design ideas to completely transform the interior spaces, update the kitchen and baths, and restore this property to its full potential. Schedule your tour today and explore the possibilities! DISCLOSURE: Property sold strictly as-is. Select listing photos feature virtually staged and conceptual renderings to demonstrate spatial layout and design possibilities. The home is currently in distressed, unfinished condition; all staged furnishings, upgrades, and proposed fixtures are conceptual only and not included in the sale.

1315 W Grant Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Aaron Galvin. F.C. Tucker Company

$360,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 2-full-bath ranch home with a dedicated office in New Palestine! Offering comfortable single-level living and a thoughtfully designed floor plan, this home features a spacious living room, formal dining room, kitchen with adjoining breakfast room, and a generously sized laundry room. The primary suite offers a spacious bathroom featuring 2 vanities, a walk-in shower and a large walk-in closet, providing both comfort and ample storage. The separate office provides an ideal space for working from home, hobbies, or a quiet retreat. The two-car garage adds everyday convenience and extra storage, along with a handy utility sink that's perfect for cleanup after gardening, outdoor projects, or other household tasks. One of the home's standout features is the wonderful outdoor living space! Step outside to discover a large patio complemented by an attractive pergola, creating an inviting extension of the home's living and entertaining areas. Whether hosting summer cookouts, enjoying dinner outdoors, gathering with friends and family, or simply relaxing with your morning coffee, this backyard offers plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. The neighborhood also features wonderful community amenities, including a park, playground, covered picnic pavilion, and scenic ponds. Conveniently located near downtown New Palestine, local parks, schools, shopping, and dining, this home offers the perfect combination of comfortable indoor living, inviting outdoor spaces, and neighborhood amenities!

3384 S Cordell Road, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Theresa Volk. Grange Real Estate

$280,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

This charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath bungalow offers peaceful country living on 2 acres, conveniently located between Thorntown and Crawfordsville. Step inside to find beautiful hardwood floors, a welcoming country kitchen, and a formal dining room perfect for gathering with family and friends. A new roof adds peace of mind, while the spacious acreage provides plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors, garden, or simply take in the quiet surroundings. Start your mornings with coffee or unwind at the end of the day on the covered front porch and enjoy the slower pace of country living. Full of charm and possibilities, this adorable bungalow is ready to welcome you home!

11422 W State Road 47, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Heather Schaller. eXp Realty, LLC

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.

Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

Newest Sugar Creek Homes for Sale

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?